One likes his machines big and loud, the other prefers them small and mostly silent. But otherwise, this Venn diagram is closer to a perfect circle: Both Watch Guys and Car Guys are infatuated with outmoded 19th-century technology, both like to say “in the metal,” and both are existentially triggered by batteries. In the contest between the luxury world’s nerdiest collector communities, the ultimate question isn’t which reigns supreme, but how to tell one from the other. 

Car Guy

Watch Guy

THINKS HE LOOKS LIKE

THINKS HE LOOKS LIKE

Paul Newman

Steve Coogan

ROME, ITALY - OCTOBER 24:  John C. Reilly and Steve Coogan attend "Stan & Ollie"  photocall during the 13th Rome Film Fest at Auditorium Parco Della Musica on October 24, 2018 in Rome, Italy.  (Photo by Vittorio Zunino Celotto/Getty Images)

  

Vittorio Zunino Celotto/Getty Images

ACTUALLY LOOKS LIKE

Randy Newman

Randy Newman during Cannes 2002 - Anheuser Busch and Hollywood Reporter Dinner with Randy Newman in Cannes, France. (Photo by George Pimentel/WireImage)

  

George Pimentel/WireImage

911, 16.4, 250, 300, quattro, 935/78, 12, 5.0

FAVORITE NUMBERS

6241, 1518, 311.30.42.30.01.005, 20, 5711, 222, 6236, 1/1

Vintage Coco Mats ball cap

Coco Mats Hat

  

Supplied

HOPES YOU NOTICE HIS

Vintage Gay Frères bracelet

Vintage Gay Frères bracelet

  

Eric Wind

IS SURE YOU’RE WRONG ABOUT

Tesla, patina, continuation cars, how you’re pronouncing “Porsche”

Jaguar E-type Lightweight Lindner at The London Classic Car Show at The ExCel Centre 10th Jan 2015 (Photo by Michael Cole/Corbis via Getty Images)

  

Michael Cole/Corbis via Getty Images

IS SURE YOU’RE WRONG ABOUT

Rolex, fauxtina, date windows, how you’re pronouncing “Jaeger”

Watchmaking, Final Assembly, 2022. .Watchmaker during the final assembly. Detail.

  

Rolex/Cédric Widmer

In a WRX STI, Alfasud, or old 356 for sure, but in the 718? ARE YOU F#&%!NG SERIOUS?

DOES HE LIKE A FLAT FOUR

Bro, on that Kermit Submariner? Siiiick.

GRM6NF Green Rolex Submariner watch reflected on black background

  

Josh Harrison/Alamy Stock Photo

HOW OFTEN HE THINKS ABOUT LUGS

Only during tech inspection.

EBM4GA A cutaway Subaru flat four engine at the 2014 Los Angeles Auto Show

  

Rolling Stock/Alamy Stock Photo

HOW OFTEN HE THINKS ABOUT LUGS

PRETENDS TO LIKE / IS ASHAMED HE ACTUALLY LIKE

Double-clutching / Self-driving technology

Gearshift

  

Fairfax Media/Getty Images/Michael Ventura/Alamy

PRETENDS TO LIKE / IS ASHAMED HE ACTUALLY LIKE

Seiko Credor / Seiko milsub mods

Seiko Watch

  

Supplied

OTHER HOBBIES HE’S ANNOYING ABOUT

Watches

OTHER HOBBIES HE’S ANNOYING ABOUT

Cars